Retirement Living takes an unbiased approach to our reviews. We may earn money when you click a partner link. Learn More
Best Home Warranty New York
We chose the best home warranty companies in New York based on coverage options, costs and customer reviews.
Updated:
American Home Shield
4.6
American Home Shield has been serving consumers for 50 years with comprehensive home warranties. Some plans have high appliance replacement limits, and all allow you to choose your service fee amount.
- Great Reputation
- High appliance replacement limits
- Available in 49 states
First American Home Warranty
4.3
First American Home Warranty offers monthly or annual payment plans and generous, customizable packages. Available in 35 states. No age limitations for appliances.
- Flexible Coverage
- Three Fee Options
- Monthly or Annual Payment
Choice Home Warranty
4.4
Choice Home Warranty offers coverage for most of your home’s major systems or appliances, and can save you from unexpected out-of-pocket expenses due to normal wear and tear. To keep policies affordable (starting at $420/year), policies cover all or nearly all of your home’s systems, but with specific exclusions. For additional coverage, warranties can be extended to cover your pool, spa, septic tank and other household systems.
- Affordable Options
- Comprehensive Coverage
- 24/7 Claims Center
Select Home Warranty
4.4
Select Home Warranty is a New Jersey-based home warranty provider that offers protection for home systems and appliances. They received the Best in Service designation from the Home Warranty Awards in 2017. Overall, we like Select Home Warranty for their favorable terms and conditions, flexible coverage options and nationwide network of contracted service providers.
- Comprehensive Plans
- Three plans with minimal exclusions
- 24/7 customer service
Liberty Home Guard
4.3
Liberty Home Guard’s three customizable home warranty plans provide homeowners with peace of mind should an appliance or major home system fail. The company quickly processes claims and dispatches vetted, qualified professionals to repair or replace what’s broken. Liberty Home Guard puts customers in control with several options to create a home warranty that’s just right.
- Great Extras
- Appliance Coverage
- Septic, gutters & more
First Premier Home Warranty
4.5
First Premier Home Warranty offers two plans to make choosing repair service coverage easy. The company also offers several optional add-ons.
- Simplified Coverage Options
- Vetted Technicians
- HVAC Perks
Cinch Home Services
4.4
Cinch Home Services offers three unique home warranty plans and offers on-demand repair services with a 180-day guarantee.
- Great Work Guarantee
- $500 homeowner insurance deductible reimbursement
- 180-day workmanship guarantee
Complete Care Home Warranty
Complete Care Home Warranty covers appliances of all ages. The home warranties offer coverage on up to 20 systems and appliances without a home inspection.
Select Home Warranty
Each Select Home Warranty plan offers $100 off, free roof coverage and two extra months of coverage for no charge upon signing up. The company sells three home warranty plans and has a rapid service response time of 24-48 hours.
The Home Service Club
The Home Service Club offers two home warranty plans. The Standard plan covers 18 household systems and appliances and the Comprehensive covers 36. Repairs completed by Home Service Club technicians are guaranteed for 90 days.
AHW Home Warranty
AHW, formerly Amazon Home Warranty, provides three home warranty plans, including the Essential Appliances, Major Systems and Combo options. 24/7 claim service is available to customers along with optional coverage add-ons for an extra fee.
Home Warranty Costs in New York
The price of a home warranty plan in New York is based on the plan you select, the size of your home and other factors, such as your payment frequency choice. In New York, home warranty plan prices average around $319 per year or roughly $26 per month. This price can increase or decrease based on the systems and appliances you choose to cover and how often you make payments toward the plan.
While New York is known for cold and icy weather during the winter months, a home warranty plan does not cover damage caused by weather. Rather, these plans cover repairs required once the original manufacturer’s warranty on an appliance or system expires.
Home Warranty for Homebuyers, Sellers and Realtors in New York
New York state experienced 131,656 closed home sales in 2019. As most realtors know, a lot can happen between the time a house goes on the market and the final closing. Home warranties can protect sellers and buyers against emergency appliances and system repairs during the home buying process.
Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty leverages a nationwide network of 15,000 licensed, insured contractors to complete home warranty claims across the United States. The company also offers the first month free for new home warranty customers. Choice Home Warranty offers two plans: the Basic Plan and Total Plan, along with optional coverage for an additional fee. Customers can also customize their plans to meet the specific needs of their homes.
Customers state that they appreciate Choice Home Warranty’s same-day repairs and service along with the company’s professionalism throughout the claim process.
| Address | Services all of New York |
| Phone Number | (888) 531-5403 |
Select Home Warranty
Select Home Warranty customers can file a claim anytime of day and have a local contractor on-site within 24 to 48 hours. The company utilizes a nationwide network of locally licensed and insured contractors to provide prompt services to customers. Home warranty plans include Bronze Care, Gold Care and Platinum Care options. Each plan offers $100 off, free roof coverage and two extra months of coverage for no charge.
Customer reviews mention great discounts for multiyear plans as well as thorough, efficient repair services.
| Address | Services all of New York |
| Phone Number | (855) 267-3532 |
The Home Service Club
The Home Service Club offers standard and comprehensive home warranty coverage plans for homeowners, buyers and sellers. The Standard Coverage plan covers 18 household systems and appliances, while the Comprehensive Coverage plan provides coverage for 36. Home warranty customers can also customize their plans by adding optional coverage, such as for outside sewer and gas lines. All Home Service Club repairs are guaranteed for 90 days, too.
Home Service Club customer reviews discuss reliable service, knowledgeable technicians, and patient and responsive customer service representatives.
| Address | 305 Broadway, seventh floor, New York, NY 10007 |
| Phone Number | (800) 601-1009 |
AHW Home Warranty
AHW Home Warranty provides three home warranty plan options for customers in the Greater New York area. Plans include Essential Appliances Plan, Major Systems Plan and theCombo Plan. Optional coverage add-ons are available upon request for an additional fee. Amazon Home Warranty utilizes the expertise of 40,000 in-network service providers across the country to provide customers with prompt, professional service. 24/7 claim service is also available.
Customer reviews mention quick claim turnaround times as well as helpful, courteous service technicians.
| Address | W. 34th St., 11th floor, New York, NY 10001 |
| Phone Number | (888) 934-0001 |