Retirement Living takes an unbiased approach to our reviews. We may earn money when you click a partner link. Learn More
Best Gold Dealers Milwaukee, WI
We chose the best gold dealers in Milwaukee, WI, based on their selection, costs and customer reviews.
Updated:
American Hartford Gold Group
4.7
American Hartford Gold specializes in gold and silver IRAs as well as buying and selling gold and silver for physical possession. It uses a quick three-step process for acquiring precious metals for physical delivery, a gold IRA, or a precious metals IRA. Its same-day IRA is the fastest in the industry, and customers can access more promotions than other gold companies.
- Great ongoing promotions
- No buyback fees
- Up to $15,000 in FREE silver on qualified accounts
Patriot Gold Group
4.8
Patriot offers a quick setup for new accounts within 24 hours. Their easy three-step process makes starting a gold IRA simple and affordable to manage.
- No-fee-for-life IRA
- Highly rated by customers
- No management fees
Goldco
4.8
Goldco offers many years of experience in both the precious metals market and precious metals IRAs. This experience lets them guide individuals through important decisions when purchasing precious metals.
- Great for customer service
- Recommends $10k minimum for IRA transfers and $5k for cash purchases
- Get up to 10% instant match in silver with a qualified account (no cap on purchase amount)
Lear Capital
4.9
Lear Capital offers low annual management costs and good customer service. It is a great choice for anyone looking to invest in a precious metals IRA.
- Great service
- Fees waived depending on investment amount
- Personalized customer service and education
Orion Metal Exchange
4.9
Orion Metals Exchange deals in precious metals. They offer clear pricing on IRS-approved metals. Plus, you might be able to waive setup and maintenance fees. It offers a variety of services, including an easy-to-set-up IRA account.
- Transparent pricing of IRS-approved precious metals
- Potential for waived fees
- Commission-free buyback policy
Sanctuary Metals
4.9
Sanctuary Metals helps retirement investors protect and grow their savings. They offer personalized investment options in gold, silver, platinum, and other precious metals.
- Great customer support
- Transparent pricing
- Reliable and excellent reputation
International Gold & Silver Buyers
Buys gold, coins and precious metals. Pays cash on the spot. Numismatic experts on staff to evaluate your coin collection. Bring in broken gold, nuggets, and gold of any kind for an evaluation.
JRS Jewelry Repair Shop
Buys and sells gold, jewelry, silver and more. Visit for a free, no-obligation appraisal. Strives to pay out the highest prices in the area. Get cash immediately.
Greater Milwaukee Coin & Jewelry
Specializes in buying and selling rare and collectible coins. Also buys gold, silver, platinum, jewelry and more. Numismatists on staff will help you select coins or appraise your collection. Belongs to AMA, NGC, PCGS and PNG.
Reflections Jewelry
Always pays cash for gold jewelry (including scrap), gold, silver, platinum and palladium bullion, and coins. Shop a wide selection of jewelry in store or check out the online catalog. Services are available in Spanish.
Shorewood Coin Shop
Buys and sells rare coins, proof and mint sets, gold and silver bullion, scrap gold, platinum, precious metal jewelry, certified coins and more. Call to set up an appointment. Will travel for large collections.
Powers Jewelry Designers
Full-service and custom jeweler offering jewelry and precious metals buying services. Buys unwanted gold, platinum, jewelry, and diamonds. Recycles your precious metals into new custom jewelry.
Harry C. Glinberg Jewelers
Family owned and operated since 1998. Offers high end and custom jewelry, along with gold and platinum buying services. Shop in store or online.
Pawn America
Sell your items in store or mail them in, with free shipping. Buys gold and precious metals. Shop online or in store. 15 day return policy on purchases.
Robert Haack Diamond Importers
Full-service jeweler also offers cash on the spot for gold, silver, platinum, and palladium items. Guaranteed to beat a competitor’s offer or you get $20. Browse the catalog online or shop in store for the most unique items.
David Derzon Coins
Specializes in helping coin collectors at all levels. Buys coins, bullion, jewelry and more. View sample coin pricing list online. Family owned and operated.
Gold and other precious metals are an investment and carry risk. Consumers should be alert to claims that customers can make a lot of money in these or any investment with little risk. As with any investment, you can lose money and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance results. Consumers should also obtain a clear understanding of the fees associated with any investment before agreeing to invest.
Gold Dealer Costs and Fees in Milwaukee, WI
Gold dealers have to make a profit somehow—that’s why they add premiums to precious metals transactions. The premium is the amount above spot price that a dealer charges. Spot price is the current price of the metal based on market conditions, which change constantly. Consumers can check spot prices on public exchange listings; dealers should refer to spot prices during the transaction. Gold premiums between 2-8% are typically a good value, but premiums on other precious metals vary.
Gold dealers must also charge sales tax when selling coins and bullion in Wisconsin. A reputable dealer will be aware of applicable sales tax and discuss how prices are determined. Ask the dealer about discounts on the premium for bulk purchases.
Milwaukee Gold Dealers Reviews
International Gold & Silver Buyers
International Gold and Silver Buyers pays cash for gold, coins, silver, platinum, palladium, iridium, diamonds and more. They also buy entire collections and estates plus industrial items such as crucibles and cylinders. The business is licensed and regulated by local officials and has been operating in the same location for 35 years. Reviewers like the owner’s honesty, friendliness, and willingness to educate customers on the market. Others said the prices they got paid for jewelry, coins, scrap gold and silver were great, with no hassling.
| Address | 6113 W Bluemound Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53213 |
| Phone Number | (414) 453-2005 |
JRS Jewelry Repair Shop
JRS Jewelry Repair Shop pays cash on the spot for gold, diamonds, silver and more. They also sell gold, watches and jewelry. The business aims to deliver personalized and friendly service and give the best prices for your unwanted gold. Visit the store for a free appraisal. Reviewers give this business five stars for honest and knowledgeable staff, fair prices, and a welcoming owner. Customers said each transaction was a pleasure.
| Address | 7239 W Greenfield Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53214 |
| Phone Number | (414) 259-6050 |
Greater Milwaukee Coin & Jewelry
Greater Milwaukee Gold & Coins buys and sells rare coins, precious metals and bullion. Customers can shop for wheat cents, old gold coins, Morgan dollars, Franklin half dollars and more. Expert coin dealers will help you find coins that you are seeking or appraise the value of your collection. Reviewers said the selection was great, pricing was competitive for buying and selling coins and precious metals, and service was honest. The staff, including professional numismatists, is knowledgeable.
| Address | 4040 N Calhoun Rd, Brookfield, WI 53005 |
| Phone Number | (262) 781-4200 |
Reflections Jewelry
Reflections Jewelry is a jewelry store and pawn shop that buys and sells gold, silver, coins and diamonds. Customers can bring in gold jewelry, scrap jewelry, bars and coins, and silver, platinum and palladium bullion. The shop also sells a huge selection of gold, bridal sets and sterling silver. Services are available in Spanish. Customers like the caring staff that puts clients first. Reviewers report good prices on jewelry, professional and fast service, and well-informed employees.
| Address | 1306 W Forest Home Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53204 |
| Phone Number | (414) 672-6108 |
Shorewood Coin Shop
Shorewood Coin Shop buys gold, silver, platinum, coins, bullion, stamps, jewelry and more. The shop specializes in rare coins and all areas of numismatics. Customers can schedule a consultation. Staff will travel to appraise large estates and waive the travel fee when buying your collection. Reviewers state that the owner was very knowledgeable about coins and offered fair prices to sellers. Others like the good prices and great selection of coins, medals and tokens.
| Address | 4409 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211 |
| Phone Number | (414) 961-0999 |
Powers Jewelry Designers
Powers Jewelry Designers is a locally owned and operated full-service jeweler offering custom design and precious metals buying services. The shop pays top dollar for your unwanted gold, platinum, gems and diamonds. Expert gemologists will evaluate your items to get you the maximum value. Designers can also use the precious metals from your jewelry to design and manufacture a new piece. Reviewers enjoy outstanding customer service, quick appraisals, and nice selection. Customers said the staff is welcoming, friendly, and knowledgeable.
| Address | 301 E Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202 |
| Phone Number | (414) 272-4510 |
Harry C. Glinberg Jewelers
Harry C. Glinberg Jewelers is a high-end full-service specialty jewelry store specializes in fine watches and diamonds and also buys gold and platinum. Customers can shop an extensive inventory online or in store. Reviewers say the jewelry and service were top notch, with fantastic selection and a fun shopping experience. Reviewers were happy with the quality of their items and reasonable prices.
| Address | 2675 N Mayfair Rd #305, Milwaukee, WI 53226 |
| Phone Number | (414) 257-2381 |
Pawn America
Pawn America is a national chain of pawn shops with online shopping and a location in Milwaukee. Customers can get a quote online and mail in items to sell with free shipping or can start a quote online and then bring items to the store for payout. Pawn America has GIA gemologists and goldsmiths on staff to evaluate your jewelry and precious metals. Customers give this shop five stars for helpful customer service, great rates and beautiful jewelry. Reviewers liked the fast transactions.
| Address | 6574 N 76th St, Milwaukee, WI 53223 |
| Phone Number | (414) 644-5761 |
Robert Haack Diamond Importers
Robert Haack Diamond Importers carries a wide selection of jewelry and loose diamonds. They also offer cash for gold, silver, platinum, palladium, dental gold, diamonds, and unwanted or broken jewelry. Customers can trade in gold for an item in the store’s inventory or have one of the store’s master goldsmiths recycle it into a new custom piece. Reviewers appreciate the professional, attentive staff who answered questions, offered fair prices, and made selling a no-pressure experience.
| Address | 7530 W Layton Ave, Greenfield, WI 53220 |
| Phone Number | (414) 281-0500 |
David Derzon Coins
David Derzon Coins is a rare coin dealer that has served the community for over 65 years. To see their selection, visit the online shop or stop by the store.They buy pre-1964 silver coins, foreign coins, select type coins, graded coins, bullion, certain circulated and commemorative coins, jewelry and more. For large collections, customers should set up an appointment. Reviewers like the excellent customer service from staff who helped them learn more about the coins they brought in and treated them with respect. Transactions were handled quickly and with fairness.
| Address | 2069 S 108th St, West Allis, WI 53227 |
| Phone Number | (414) 543-8833 |