Retirement Living takes an unbiased approach to our reviews. We may earn money when you click a partner link. Learn More
Best Gold Dealers in Cincinnati, OH
We chose the best gold dealers in Cincinnati, OH, based on their selection, costs and customer reviews.
Updated:
American Hartford Gold Group
4.7
American Hartford Gold specializes in gold and silver IRAs as well as buying and selling gold and silver for physical possession. It uses a quick three-step process for acquiring precious metals for physical delivery, a gold IRA, or a precious metals IRA. Its same-day IRA is the fastest in the industry, and customers can access more promotions than other gold companies.
- Great ongoing promotions
- No buyback fees
- Up to $15,000 in FREE silver on qualified accounts
Patriot Gold Group
4.8
Patriot offers a quick setup for new accounts within 24 hours. Their easy three-step process makes starting a gold IRA simple and affordable to manage.
- No-fee-for-life IRA
- Highly rated by customers
- No management fees
Goldco
4.8
Goldco offers many years of experience in both the precious metals market and precious metals IRAs. This experience lets them guide individuals through important decisions when purchasing precious metals.
- Great for customer service
- Recommends $10k minimum for IRA transfers and $5k for cash purchases
- Get up to 10% instant match in silver with a qualified account (no cap on purchase amount)
Lear Capital
4.9
Lear Capital offers low annual management costs and good customer service. It is a great choice for anyone looking to invest in a precious metals IRA.
- Great service
- Fees waived depending on investment amount
- Personalized customer service and education
Orion Metal Exchange
4.9
Orion Metals Exchange deals in precious metals. They offer clear pricing on IRS-approved metals. Plus, you might be able to waive setup and maintenance fees. It offers a variety of services, including an easy-to-set-up IRA account.
- Transparent pricing of IRS-approved precious metals
- Potential for waived fees
- Commission-free buyback policy
Sanctuary Metals
4.9
Sanctuary Metals helps retirement investors protect and grow their savings. They offer personalized investment options in gold, silver, platinum, and other precious metals.
- Great customer support
- Transparent pricing
- Reliable and excellent reputation
The Money Vault Jewelry & Loan
Pawn or sell your gold for cash. Pays per market value or based on craftsmanship of your gold item. No minimum or maximum pawn amount.
Geraci Fine Jewelry
Full-service family jeweler in the industry since 1982. Custom design specialists on staff. Provides gold and silver buying services. Sells one-ounce gold and silver American Eagles. Financing options.
Coins Plus
Numismatists and coin experts on staff to buy and sell coins. Deals in coins, bars, gold, silver, platinum and palladium bullion. Buys scrap jewelry or large estates. Provides expert appraisals.
Franklin Street Coin Company
Contact the shop to buy, sell or trade coins. Buys silver and gold. Speak with a full-service collectibles dealer or a coin expert. Learn about currency and metals.
Queen City Rare Coin
Evaluates and buys a diverse selection of coins, including ancient and world coins. Sell your scrap jewelry and bullion or buy coins, collectibles, and artifacts.
American Trading Company
Buys a wide variety of scrap gold items, including placer gold and nuggets, as well as other coins and bullion. Stop by for a free verbal quote and get the highest payout on rare coins.
Gold and other precious metals are an investment and carry risk. Consumers should be alert to claims that customers can make a lot of money in these or any investment with little risk. As with any investment, you can lose money and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance results. Consumers should also obtain a clear understanding of the fees associated with any investment before agreeing to invest.
Buying Gold From a Gold Dealer in Cincinnati, Ohio
Despite paying premiums to dealers, Cincinnati residents interested in investing in gold and precious metals are in luck: there is no sales tax on bullion and coin sales. Physical precious metal assets could be subject to income tax when sold or liquidated.
There are several precious metal dealers in Cincinnati. However, their prices will fluctuate depending on the market and current spot price. Spot is expressed as price per ounce and is listed publicly—but it’s not the same as the price you’ll pay when buying precious metals. Gold dealers add a premium to precious metals sales to ensure a profit. The premium represents the percentage or flat rate above the spot that the dealer is charging. Premiums vary between types of metal and form, for example, coins or bars, and also differ between dealers.
Cincinnati Gold Dealers Reviews
The Money Vault Jewelry & Loan
Pawn valuables and get cash for your gold at The Money Vault Jewelry & Loan. The shop pays based on current market value and karat. For highly collectible items, the staff will consider the item’s design and craftsmanship before making an offer. Customers gave this business five stars for a friendly atmosphere, the best customer service, and great experiences. Reviewers said the Money Vault always tries to work with them and help them out. Several customers mentioned good prices when buying jewelry, firearms and electronics.
| Address | 2190 Queen City Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45214 |
| Phone Number | (513) 834-5928 |
Geraci Fine Jewelry
Geraci Fine Jewelry is a full-service jeweler providing gold and silver buying and selling services. Shop for silver and gold one-ounce American Eagles. Financing options are available. Reviewers gave Geraci Fine Jewelry five stars for its remarkable service, wonderful selection, and impeccable attention to detail. Customers liked that the staff offered personalized attention and treated them like family.
| Address | 9212 Colerain Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45251 |
| Phone Number | (513) 385-4653 |
Coins Plus
Coins Plus has been serving the Cincinnati area since 1972. One of its partners is a life member of the American Numismatic Association and was named dealer of the year in 2013. The business is a PNG member and accredited precious metals dealer. Visit to buy and sell rare coins, all forms of bullion, bulk coins like silver dollars, proof and mint sets, foreign coins, commemoratives, and more. Pure gold is also accepted. Coins Plus also provides expert appraisals and estate-buying services.
Customers gave Coins Plus five stars for competitive rates on coins, knowledgeable staff, and good selection. Reviewers liked that their items for sale were tested using state-of-the-art technology. One customer especially appreciated that the owner took the time to explain valuation and pricing.
| Address | 7760 Beechmont Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45255 |
| Phone Number | (513) 233-2646 |
Franklin Street Coin Company
Franklin Street Coin Company buys, sells, and trades coins and currency. Talk with a full-service collectibles dealer and coin expert to explain the inventory or appraise your goods. Inventory is always changing, including rare old coins dating to 1793 and coins from China, Peru, and Spanish coins. The shop also buys gold and silver. Customers gave this store high marks for the best silver and gold prices and excellent selection. Several reviewers mentioned that the staff and owner are friendly, professional, fair, and trustworthy. One reviewer said it was really fun to browse in the shop.
| Address | 10742 Reading Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45241 |
| Phone Number | (513) 554-0851 |
Queen City Rare Coin
Queen City Rare Coin buys and sells coins, currency, foreign currency, gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and other collectibles. Visit the website to review a detailed list of what the shop will buying. The store is open on Saturdays.
Queen City Rare Coin has a very high online rating. Customers say that this shop pays out more than melt value on some silver and that employees take time to evaluate items carefully. Reviewers agree that the staff is helpful and knowledgeable and gives them the best offers. More than one person cited good prices and pleasant experiences.
| Address | 9685 Kenwood Rd, Blue Ash, OH 45242 |
| Phone Number | (513) 791-2646 |
American Trading Company
Stop by American Trading Company for a free verbal quote on your coins and currency, scrap gold, platinum, silver and gold jewelry, or bullion. Talk with a coin expert to determine how much your coins are worth: American Eagles, Krugerrands and Maple Leafs, U.S. silver coins and generic .999 fine bars and rounds. The store also buys and sells collectibles.
Customers said this shop was always a fair deal and that staff gave them plenty of information about the history and value of their items. Reviewers liked visiting the shop and said going inside was like walking into an antique museum.
| Address | 3209 Galbraith Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45239 |
| Phone Number | (513) 385-6789 |