Retirement Living takes an unbiased approach to our reviews. We may earn money when you click a partner link. Learn More
Wheelchair Lift vs. Ramp
Wheelchair lifts and ramps both make homes safer and more accessible for people who use wheelchairs, but they differ in design, operation, and price.
Updated:
AT A GLANCE:
- Wheelchair lifts are powered platforms that carry wheelchair users up and down between levels; wheelchair ramps are surfaces that slope gradually to connect different levels.
- The most common types of wheelchair lifts are vertical platform lifts, inclined platform lifts, and portable lifts. Wheelchair ramps can be customized for many different spaces, like thresholds and vehicles.
- Choosing between a lift and a ramp depends on your specific needs, the location of installation, and whether the need is temporary or long-term.
If you use a mobility aid, such as a wheelchair, and are looking for ways to increase accessibility and safety at home, installing a wheelchair lift or ramp is worth considering. Both enable wheelchair users to travel between areas of different elevations. However, while they share some similarities, lifts and ramps are quite different from each other, both in design and operation.
To determine which lift option is best for you, we explore the differences between wheelchair lifts and wheelchair ramps, reviewing their costs, types, and pros and cons.
What’s a Wheelchair Lift?
A wheelchair lift is a platform lift that enables wheelchair users to travel between two or more levels. It functions much like an elevator; however, unlike a home elevator, a wheelchair lift is not fully enclosed, it has a lower weight capacity, and it is more cost-effective.
Wheelchair lifts can be installed for indoor or outdoor use to travel between porches, decks, or floors, depending on your mobility needs. They are designed to accommodate various mobility devices, including power chairs, scooters, wheelchairs, and more.
Different Types of Wheelchair Lifts
There are three types of wheelchair lifts commonly used: vertical platform lifts, inclined platform lifts, and portable lifts. Each transports wheelchair users between levels, but their primary function differs slightly.
Below, we explore the main types of wheelchair lifts to help you understand the differences and identify which mobility solution best suits your needs.
1. Vertical Platform Lifts
A vertical platform lift (VPL) moves a wheelchair and its user between levels by raising and lowering a platform along a vertical path. Vertical platform lifts can be used in both homes and public spaces. They are often installed by porches, raised entryways, or to connect interior levels where ramps aren’t practical.
When installing a vertical wheelchair lift, consider whether you need an unenclosed or enclosed setup.
- Unenclosed lifts: These open designs (often called porch lifts) are commonly placed outside a home to connect the ground with a porch or raised entryway. They are cost-effective for outdoor use and include safety gates.
- Enclosed lifts: These lifts are equipped with walls, a platform gate, and a landing gate, creating a contained space for the rider. They provide extra security and protection, and are often used for indoor units.
You can expect the cost of a vertical platform lift to range between $9,000 and $20,000, including equipment and installation.
2. Inclined Platform Lifts
Inclined platform lifts (IPL) travel along an inclined path, like stairs, carrying a wheelchair and its user between levels. They can be fitted to existing staircases, including straight and curved stairways.
The main parts of an inclined platform lift include:
- The Track: This is easily wall-mounted or installed onto a post system that is secured to the stair treads, allowing the platform to travel up and down safely.
- The Platform: Some platforms allow access from two or three sides and can be folded to save space or remain non-folding.
The average cost of an inclined platform lift is between $2,000 and $15,000. However, some inclined platform lifts can reach up to $35,000, depending on the type of staircase, manufacturer, model, and additional safety features.
3. Portable Lifts
A portable wheelchair lift is a mobile, temporary, ADA-compliant accessibility solution that provides wheelchair users access to various locations, like stages, platforms, and sometimes vehicles. They are freestanding units and are commonly used for travel, events, or locations where permanent installation isn’t feasible.
Portable wheelchair lifts can be designed for either vertical or inclined paths, but vertical lifts are most common.
The average price range for portable wheelchair lifts is between $900 and $12,000. However, some newer, more advanced models can reach up to $20,000.
Pros and Cons of Wheelchair Lifts
Wheelchair lifts offer many benefits, like enhanced independence for those with mobility challenges, increased accessibility, and safety. However, there are some drawbacks to installing a wheelchair lift that you should consider before purchasing a unit.
Pros
- Increased mobility
- Ease of use
- Versatility
- Space efficient
- Easier to install than an elevator
- Minimal structural changes to the home
- Increased home value
- Reduced burden to caregivers
Cons
- Travel height is limited (usually to 14 feet)
- More costly than solutions like stairlifts
- Needs regular checks and maintenance
- Not always aesthetically pleasing
- Loading and unloading can be time-consuming
What is a Wheelchair Ramp?
A wheelchair ramp is a sloped surface that acts as an alternative to stairs for people who use wheelchairs, scooters, rollators, and more. They allow easy and safe passage between areas of different elevations for those with mobility issues. They can be permanent or temporary and are designed to enhance accessibility and independence and meet ADA guidelines.
Types of Wheelchair Ramps
There are several types of wheelchair ramps to consider. Most permanent wheelchair ramps will cost between $1,000 and $10,000. However, price can be based on the number of pieces and the material. Smaller ramps can be as little as $200, while more complex models can reach up to $20,000.
1. Modular Ramps
Modular ramps are composed of individual, connectable sections (i.e., ramp surfaces, platforms, legs, connectors) that bolt together. This multi-piece setup allows for customization, creating a versatile accessibility solution for specific areas.
These aluminum wheelchair ramps allow you to create a short or long ramp, depending on your personal preference, available space, and mobility needs.
2. Threshold Ramps
Threshold ramps are typically small, lightweight ramps, made from either rubber or aluminum, that provide smooth travel over a low-rise threshold or single steps. These are a cost-effective solution for wheelchair users that provide sturdy, non-slip access without the need for major renovations.
3. Portable Ramps
As their name suggests, portable ramps can be moved from one location to another, providing access to areas that would otherwise be inaccessible to those with limited mobility. Some portable ramps include foldable, telescoping, and roll-up models.
Installing a portable ramp ensures accessibility without altering the environment. They are great for temporary needs, meeting ADA requirements without going against any building codes.
4. Vehicle Ramps
Vehicle ramps are another common type of wheelchair ramp. These are similar to portable ramps but are designed specifically to allow wheelchair users to access a vehicle, typically a wheelchair van. Some vehicle ramps can be installed on the van itself, while others act as removable attachments.
Pros and Cons of Wheelchair Ramps
Wheelchair ramps increase independence at home and on the road, ensuring safety and easy access to different areas. However, there are some complications to consider.
Pros
- More affordable than wheelchair lifts
- Versatile in design and location
- Durablitity
- Long-lasting materials
- Customizable layout
- Choice of materials
- Power ramp options available
- Easy installation
Cons
- Require more space
- Not aesthetically pleasing
- May require assistance to navigate
- Weather may impact functionality or warp materials
- Some ramps lack handrails
- May become uneven over time
Choosing Between a Wheelchair Lift and a Ramp
Choosing between a wheelchair lift and a wheelchair ramp depends on your specific needs, the location of installation, whether the need is temporary or long-term, and more.
Ask yourself the following questions when choosing between a lift and a ramp for your home.
- What is the height difference between the areas you want to travel between? Ramps are best for small inclines over short distances, while lifts are best for greater heights, usually reaching up to 14 feet.
- What is the weather like where you live? Outdoor ramps must be cleared of snow and ice before they can be safely used, and rain can make them slippery. Outdoor lifts can be covered for all-weather protection.
- Who will be using the mobility solution? Consider the user’s capacity, including strength, endurance, and dexterity, as well as the type of wheelchair or mobility device they use. Ramps can be more challenging to navigate, especially for manual wheelchair users; lifts are easy to use for almost everyone, but some may struggle with the controls.
- How long will you need it? Both lifts and ramps are great for long-term solutions; however, module wheelchair ramps are best for temporary access as they are more affordable and require little to no home modifications.
- What is your budget? While wheelchair ramps are generally more affordable than wheelchair lifts, that isn’t always the case. The longer the ramp, the more pieces are needed to safely transport the user between levels, which increases costs. A wheelchair lift may be the best option for greater height differences.
- How much space is available? To meet guidelines, longer ramps require more space to ensure safe, easy access. However, lifts simply move up and down, taking up less space, making them ideal for homes with limited space.
If you’re still unsure whether a wheelchair lift or ramp is best for you and your loved ones, contact a professional to help you identify which accessibility solution best meets your needs.
Bottom Line: Deciding Between a Wheelchair Lift vs. a Ramp Comes Down to Your Space, Budget, and Mobility Needs
Homeowners looking to make their home wheelchair accessible for themselves and their loved ones have many high-quality lift options to choose from. In addition to accessibility solutions like home elevators, you can install wheelchair lifts and wheelchair ramps to ensure easy access between areas.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Wheelchair Lifts vs. Ramps
A wheelchair ramp is a surface that slopes gradually, providing access between two different levels for wheelchair users. It requires no power, in most cases, and can be easily customized for different areas. A wheelchair lift is a powered platform that transports wheelchairs and their users up and down between levels. Lifts require no manual effort to operate and can travel higher distances than ramps.
The ADA has many standards to ensure platform lifts are safe and functional. A few of the main requirements for lifts to be compliant include having enough space for the wheelchair to maneuver, slip-resistant surfaces, utilizing safety features such as automatic gates and emergency stops, meeting strict platform size requirements, and ensuring proper clearance heights.
Wheelchair ramps are more cost-effective for low rises with enough space, while wheelchair lifts are more practical and cost-effective for larger rises (over three feet) and for areas with limited space.
No, Medicare doesn’t pay for wheelchair ramps because they aren’t considered durable medical equipment under the original plans. However, some Medicare Advantage plans may cover ramps as supplemental benefits.
In most cases, yes, you will need a permit to install a wheelchair ramp, especially a permanent one. This is because they are considered home additions and require safety checks for compliance with local building codes and ADA standards. However, portable/threshold ramps may not need one, so be sure to check with the city before installation.
Help us improve our guides! If you’ve recently purchased or installed a platform lift or have insights on how yours works, we’d love to hear from you. Share your experience with us at [email protected]. Your personal details will stay completely confidential.