Retirement Living takes an unbiased approach to our reviews. We may earn money when you click a partner link. Learn More
Best Gold Dealers in New York, NY
We chose the best gold dealers in New York, New York based on selection, cost and customer reviews.
Updated:
American Hartford Gold Group
4.7
American Hartford Gold specializes in gold and silver IRAs as well as buying and selling gold and silver for physical possession. It uses a quick three-step process for acquiring precious metals for physical delivery, a gold IRA, or a precious metals IRA. Its same-day IRA is the fastest in the industry, and customers can access more promotions than other gold companies.
- Great ongoing promotions
- No buyback fees
- Up to $15,000 in FREE silver on qualified accounts
Patriot Gold Group
4.8
Patriot offers a quick setup for new accounts within 24 hours. Their easy three-step process makes starting a gold IRA simple and affordable to manage.
- No-fee-for-life IRA
- Highly rated by customers
- No management fees
Goldco
4.8
Goldco offers many years of experience in both the precious metals market and precious metals IRAs. This experience lets them guide individuals through important decisions when purchasing precious metals.
- Great for customer service
- Recommends $10k minimum for IRA transfers and $5k for cash purchases
- Get up to 10% instant match in silver with a qualified account (no cap on purchase amount)
Lear Capital
4.9
Lear Capital offers low annual management costs and good customer service. It is a great choice for anyone looking to invest in a precious metals IRA.
- Great service
- Fees waived depending on investment amount
- Personalized customer service and education
Orion Metal Exchange
4.9
Orion Metals Exchange deals in precious metals. They offer clear pricing on IRS-approved metals. Plus, you might be able to waive setup and maintenance fees. It offers a variety of services, including an easy-to-set-up IRA account.
- Transparent pricing of IRS-approved precious metals
- Potential for waived fees
- Commission-free buyback policy
Sanctuary Metals
4.9
Sanctuary Metals helps retirement investors protect and grow their savings. They offer personalized investment options in gold, silver, platinum, and other precious metals.
- Great customer support
- Transparent pricing
- Reliable and excellent reputation
Bullion Trading LLC
Buy four different precious metals in a variety of weights with a choice of collector bars or coins from different countries. Purchase a single coin or get a quantity discount for buying certain items in bulk.
Sell Gold NYC
Pays immediate cash for gold with the best price guaranteed. Bring gold jewelry, gold scrap, coins and watches for a free estimate. View price per ounce online. Deals directly with respected refineries around the world.
Bullion Exchanges
Purchase coins, bars and other collectibles from domestic and international mints. Open a precious metals IRA. Offers a price match guarantee on all bullion products. Sign up for the rewards program online to earn credit toward future purchases
AGR Gold
Buy or sell gold and precious metals. Gold storage also available. Comprehensive selection of weights and mints. Shop online or in-person at the Midtown location. Member of the NGC and American Numismatic Association.
Empire Gold Buyers
Lists payout prices online. Ship your gold for a free appraisal and immediate payout. Pays up to 96% of market value with higher prices for larger volumes. Free shipping
Global Gold & Silver, Inc.
Private, no-cost appraisal service with Brooklyn and Midtown locations. Buys gold and precious metal. Sells jewelry. Certified technicians and jewelry appraisers in-house. Some appraisals and payouts in fewer than 10 minutes.
Gold and other precious metals are an investment and carry risk. Consumers should be alert to claims that customers can make a lot of money in these or any investment with little risk. As with any investment, you can lose money and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance results. Consumers should also obtain a clear understanding of the fees associated with any investment before agreeing to invest.
Gold Dealer Costs and Fees in New York, NY
Gold is a great diversification investment, but the costs can vary significantly depending on the dealer. Customers in New York can expect to pay around $130 above spot price per ounce for American Eagle coins and around $100 above spot price per ounce for a bar of gold.
Another cost associated with physical gold (bullion) investment is storage. Storing gold at home is not recommended; most likely, you’ll be paying fees to a bank or storage facility to keep your investment safe.
We recommend speaking with at least three dealers before making your purchase to ensure you are getting the best quality for the best price.
New York Gold Dealers Reviews
Bullion Trading LLC
Bullion Trading sells a variety of metals including gold, silver, palladium and platinum. Select from a collection of coins or bars in various weights ranging from 100 grams to one kilogram and choose from a range of different imprints. Bullion Trading offers a quantity discount on most items. Prices are transparent and listed on the website for easy browsing. The price you see is the price you get. Anything you buy from the company will be bought back from this same company. Purchase in person in Midtown or shop online. Customers liked the easy transaction process, fair prices and helpful, honest salespeople.
| Address | 20 West 47th Street Lower Level #24, New York, NY 10036 |
| Phone Number | (212) 997-2520 |
Sell Gold NYC
Sell Gold NYC or Royal Gems Corp is a certified and registered precious metal dealer. The company pays immediate cash for gold including jewelry, watches and coins. Prices paid per ounce are listed online. Customers can sell online or in-person on 47th Street, where they can also get a free quote. Reviewers mentioned the process was simple and quick, and many got cash offers that were higher than other buyers in the area. Customers said the staff was welcoming and friendly.
| Address | 55 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036 |
| Phone Number | (877) 814-3432 |
Bullion Exchanges
Bullion Exchanges sells gold, silver, palladium and platinum in collectible coins, bars and other forms. Find unusual products like antique German coins or silver Pepsi bottle caps. Choose from a wide range of weights along with coins from mints all around the world. Bullion Exchanges also sets up precious metal IRA accounts for customers. Visit in-person in Midtown or buy online. Get a discount for bulk orders. Accepts PayPal, credit card, bitcoin, check, wire or ACH. The company also buys coins, bullion and jewelry. Reviewers liked the responsive customer service and large selection.
| Address | 30 W 47th St Store 1, New York, NY 10036 |
| Phone Number | (212) 354-1517 |
Manhattan Gold & Silver
Manhattan Gold and Silver sells a variety of gold bullion products, such as bars, coins and fractionals. The company also provides precious metal refining services with same-day payouts, right in Midtown. Compare current precious metal prices on the company website before buying, or get a quote in person before selling. Download the free app for precious metal price charts and trends. Customers experienced honest, friendly and prompt service with fair prices.
| Address | 45 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036 |
| Phone Number | (212) 398-1454 |
AGR Gold
AGR Gold sells, buys and stores gold and precious metals. Gold is available in a large selection of bars or coins from U.S. or international mints. Shop online for an interesting collection of antique coins. AGR also offers gold, silver, palladium and platinum pool accounts as a lower-cost way of investing in precious metals. Customers can pay through PayPal and cryptocurrency. Customers said the staff was professional and made them feel comfortable
| Address | 31 W 47th St STE 504, New York, NY 10036 |
| Phone Number | (212) 391-1012 |
Empire Gold Buyers
Empire Gold Buyers pays up to 96% of gold’s true market value, and the company’s payout structure starts at three troy ounces. Its parent company is a gold refiner, so there is no middleman. Overnight your gold for a free same-day estimate and payout, or visit in-person by appointment. Payout options include check, PayPal, MoneyGram, Western Union or direct deposit. Customers said they received great prices, and the staff was polite. One reviewer especially liked the company’s good reputation with the Better Business Bureau.
| Address | 370 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10017 |
| Phone Number | (888) 949-3674 |
Global Gold & Silver, Inc
Global Gold & Silver offers a private appraisal service with payouts in as little as ten minutes. Choose check or cash; sell in-person or by mail. This company buys gold, silver, rings, jewelry and more. Sellers are encouraged to ask questions and learn about the process. Reviewers liked the low-pressure environment and courteous staff along with competitive prices. Several customers said they appreciated that representatives took the time to educate them on the gold buying and selling process.
| Address | 7 W 45th St #1200, New York, NY 10036 |
| Phone Number | (212) 302-4653 |